FULL TEXT
LETTER TO THE EDITOR
APSP J Case Rep 2010; Vol. 1 (2)
OPEN
ACCESS
Conjoined Twins: The Flip Side
Tayyaba Batool,* Jamshed Akhtar
Department of Paediatric Surgery, National Institute of Child Health Karachi, Pakistan
*Corresponding Author's E-mail address: docnich2003@yahoo.com
APSP J Case Rep 2010; 1: 23
How to cite
Batool T, Akhtar J. Conjoined twins: The flip side. APSP J Case Rep 2010;1: 23
Dear Sir
The birth of conjoined twins always raises interest among medical community as well as general public [1]. The perspective of parents is often not discussed. In addition, the role of electronic and print media, in creating hype raises many questions [2]. We report a case of conjoined twins [Image 1] where many lateral issues influenced the management.
The twins were referred to us for further management after regional pediatric surgical department showed its inability to deal with the case. The family was not counseled and thee transfer was unsupervised. The referring department also made no contact with our team. Babies were brought in, by maternal uncle. Mother did not accompany the newborns, as she was unwell. At arrival babies were not in good condition. One of the twins was having respiratory distress. Immediate resuscitative measures were taken and neonatal care provided. Within hours the decision was made to intubate and mechanically ventilate the pair. However at that time only one ventilator was available, therefore twin 2, who was in critical condition, ventilated. The clinical condition stabilized. Further imaging studies like x-rays, ultrasound and echocardiography were carried out to understand anatomy of fusion and identify associated anomalies.
The family was repeatedly counseled and updated with the progress and future plans discussed. The father of the twins, a labourer, was in Middle East country and not in favour of any treatment. The second major distraction in the management of these twins was print and electronic media. Scores of them were wrangling up and down in the hospital building, around the clock. They were busy interviewing the uncle and kept him under stress. Out of desperation he eventually requested the medical team to either operate or discharge the babies, as he could not wait any further. Although babies started improving clinically but still needed in-hospital care. It was also too premature to decide about separation at this stage, therefore it was decided not to send them home. The family did not agree and left the hospital with the twins.
Conjoined Twins: The Flip Side
Tayyaba Batool,* Jamshed Akhtar
Department of Paediatric Surgery, National Institute of Child Health Karachi, Pakistan
*Corresponding Author's E-mail address: docnich2003@yahoo.com
APSP J Case Rep 2010; 1: 23
How to cite
Batool T, Akhtar J. Conjoined twins: The flip side. APSP J Case Rep 2010;1: 23
Dear Sir
The birth of conjoined twins always raises interest among medical community as well as general public [1]. The perspective of parents is often not discussed. In addition, the role of electronic and print media, in creating hype raises many questions [2]. We report a case of conjoined twins [Image 1] where many lateral issues influenced the management.
The twins were referred to us for further management after regional pediatric surgical department showed its inability to deal with the case. The family was not counseled and thee transfer was unsupervised. The referring department also made no contact with our team. Babies were brought in, by maternal uncle. Mother did not accompany the newborns, as she was unwell. At arrival babies were not in good condition. One of the twins was having respiratory distress. Immediate resuscitative measures were taken and neonatal care provided. Within hours the decision was made to intubate and mechanically ventilate the pair. However at that time only one ventilator was available, therefore twin 2, who was in critical condition, ventilated. The clinical condition stabilized. Further imaging studies like x-rays, ultrasound and echocardiography were carried out to understand anatomy of fusion and identify associated anomalies.
The family was repeatedly counseled and updated with the progress and future plans discussed. The father of the twins, a labourer, was in Middle East country and not in favour of any treatment. The second major distraction in the management of these twins was print and electronic media. Scores of them were wrangling up and down in the hospital building, around the clock. They were busy interviewing the uncle and kept him under stress. Out of desperation he eventually requested the medical team to either operate or discharge the babies, as he could not wait any further. Although babies started improving clinically but still needed in-hospital care. It was also too premature to decide about separation at this stage, therefore it was decided not to send them home. The family did not agree and left the hospital with the twins.
Website developed by Bilal Mirza
Many issues surfaced in relation to the case presented. In the
absence of social services and patient counselors, decision making is hampered.
There is a dire need of such integrated services, especially in paediatric
diseases. The role of society in general and media in particular, is very
important and has to be re-defined in the background of contemporary practices.
Media can educate the society rather than creating hype, by portraying the
unusual anomaly. The issues of privacy and confidentiality were violated. Making
films without permission, threatening hospital staff, trespassing, violating
hospital protocols and forcefully entering into intensive care units, are all
illegal but even administration of public sector hospital remained mull in this
situation. Incorrect information was telecast without even asking experts in the
field of medicine. The treating physicians thus become dejected and
disappointed.
In all this debate the one who suffers most is the patient, who is at heart of entire event. In the past surviving conjoined twins were exploited and their anomaly was used to entertain people. It appears that legacy of yesteryears is still persisting in the developing countries like Pakistan, and on this occasion by print and electronic media. It is time to realize that patient and their families with unusual anomalies, have the right to enjoy as normal a life, as possible. Their right to live independently without interference cannot denied.
Treating physicians must understand their responsibilities to patients and their families. Multiple counseling sessions without any interference and influence, in a relax atmosphere must be ensured, so as to make truly informed choices. State too has the responsibility to extend all possible help in such cases. An ethical discourse can change the existing scenario [3].
REFERENCES
1. Walker K. The tragedy that should never have happened. Can Med Assoc J 2007;177:312.
2. Hoffman K. Minnesota's Abby and Brittany Hensel, conjoined twins, make Newsweek. 2008. Accessed on November 3, 2010 available at URL http://blogs.citypages.com/blotter/2008/02/minnesotas_abby.php
3. Kessel R. One of us. J R Soc Med. 2004;97:603-4.
In all this debate the one who suffers most is the patient, who is at heart of entire event. In the past surviving conjoined twins were exploited and their anomaly was used to entertain people. It appears that legacy of yesteryears is still persisting in the developing countries like Pakistan, and on this occasion by print and electronic media. It is time to realize that patient and their families with unusual anomalies, have the right to enjoy as normal a life, as possible. Their right to live independently without interference cannot denied.
Treating physicians must understand their responsibilities to patients and their families. Multiple counseling sessions without any interference and influence, in a relax atmosphere must be ensured, so as to make truly informed choices. State too has the responsibility to extend all possible help in such cases. An ethical discourse can change the existing scenario [3].
REFERENCES
1. Walker K. The tragedy that should never have happened. Can Med Assoc J 2007;177:312.
2. Hoffman K. Minnesota's Abby and Brittany Hensel, conjoined twins, make Newsweek. 2008. Accessed on November 3, 2010 available at URL http://blogs.citypages.com/blotter/2008/02/minnesotas_abby.php
3. Kessel R. One of us. J R Soc Med. 2004;97:603-4.
IMAGES